How to hire your first sales manager: a guide for business owners

Hire your first sales manager when the process is documented, there are sales reps to lead and the owner is stuck managing the team. Look for someone who knows how to develop people and run the operation by the numbers, not just someone who sells well. Without process, targets and data, the hire tends to fail within a few months.

For many companies, this is the riskiest hire of the growth phase. The wrong manager costs salary, months of operation and, sometimes, your best sales reps. This guide is for the owner who has already decided to step out of the day-to-day. If you're still deciding how to step out, start with how the owner steps out of the sales operation. Here the subject is the hire itself.

Do you need a manager yet?

Before opening the position, check the conditions. The more items are missing, the greater the risk.

When the first two are missing, the choice may be different: structure things first, with internal or outside help, and hire afterward. On a very small team, a senior sales rep with a team lead role can be an intermediate step.

Promote from within or hire from outside?

The classic mistake is promoting the best sales rep as a reward. Selling and managing are different jobs. People who sell well love closing; people who manage well love watching someone else close. If you want to reward a great sales rep who doesn't want to lead, use a career plan with an individual contributor track.

Which profile should you look for?

First write down what the manager needs to deliver. Only then describe the person. In a company hiring its first manager, the profile is usually that of a "builder," not a maintainer.

Essential skills

• Developing people: coaches, gives feedback and sits in on meetings.
• Running by the numbers: reads the funnel, conversion and pipeline and turns that into action.
• Building process: writes it, tests it and adjusts it.
• Selling alongside the team: can step into a tough negotiation without taking over everything.
• Working with marketing: discusses lead quality and channels with solid arguments.

Warning signs

• Only talks about individual results: "I sold," never "the team grew."
• Comes from large operations with the whole structure already in place and shows no willingness to do the basics.
• Always blames failures on product, marketing or the market.
• Can't tell you the numbers from their previous operation.

Experience at a large company isn't a problem. The problem is never having built anything. Ask what already existed when the person arrived.

How do you set compensation?

There's no universal figure. Research your market, city and company size. Three precautions help design the offer:

• A base salary that sustains the role. A manager building a process can't depend on commission alone at the start.
• Variable pay tied to the team. Pay for the team's results, never for their own sales. Commission on individual sales creates competition with the sales reps.
• A transition period. In the first months, consider a guarantee or implementation targets, such as an up-to-date CRM and rituals running.

See how to design this in sales variable compensation.

Take Nexo's free assessment and confirm whether your operation is ready to bring on a sales manager.
Take the free assessment

How do you run the hiring process?

1. Write the job description around results

Instead of "lead the team," write: "Within six months, have a weekly pipeline review, documented onboarding and a reliable sales forecast."

2. Ask for a real analysis

Prepare a case with the company's real data or an anonymized version, after signing a nondisclosure agreement. Hand over the funnel and ask: "Where would you act first?". A good answer asks questions before prescribing.

3. Ask about the past

Open-ended behavioral questions reveal more than hypotheticals:

4. Run a coaching simulation

Ask the person to review an authorized recording of a sale and give feedback to a sales rep in a simulated session. You'll see how they teach. Use the guide to productive 1:1 sessions as a reference for evaluating.

5. Check the right references

If possible, talk to people the candidate has managed, in addition to former bosses. Ask: "What did you learn from them?" and "Would you work with them again?".

6. Include the team at the end

A short conversation with the team helps you see the fit. The decision is still yours, but the team understands the change better when it takes part.

What should the first 90 days look like?

Many hires fail because there's no onboarding plan, not because of a bad choice. A roadmap:

Days 1 to 30: learn

• Sit in on meetings and read conversations.
• Sell to or serve a few customers to get a feel for the process.
• Talk one-on-one with each sales rep.
• Understand the data, marketing and reasons for lost deals.
• Deliver an assessment with the three biggest problems.

Days 31 to 60: organize

• Take over the weekly pipeline review. Use the review cadence.
• Start weekly 1:1s.
• Fix funnel criteria and CRM fields.
• Agree with marketing on the definition of a qualified lead.

Days 61 to 90: take over

• Own the sales forecast.
• Take on the team's targets.
• Propose a plan for the next six months.
• Make decisions within their authority without going through the owner.

What changes in the owner's role?

The hire often fails because the owner doesn't step out. Agree on a few rules:

• Sales reps no longer bring issues straight to you.
• Disagreements are handled in private, never in front of the team.
• You can step into agreed strategic accounts, not any negotiation.
• A weekly meeting with the manager, with a metrics agenda.

If you change the rules on your own, the manager's authority disappears within a week. Announce the change to the team and to any customers affected. From then on, stick to it.

What should you prepare before the manager arrives?

A good start begins before day one. If the person arrives and finds no access, no numbers and no context, they'll lose weeks hunting for information. Put together a simple package:

• access to the CRM, customer service tools and marketing reports;
• sales history, targets and reasons for lost deals from recent periods;
• the current playbook, price list, discount policy and commission plan;
• a list of strategic accounts and what was agreed with each one;
• a presentation to the team, given by you, explaining why the role was created.

Also share what isn't working. Hiding problems to make a good impression only delays the assessment. Agree, too, on which decisions belong to the manager from day one and which will be handed over over time. In particular, make clear whether they can hire and fire, because that question usually comes up in the first month and weighs on their authority with the team.

How do you evaluate the manager in the first months?

Don't evaluate on revenue alone, because it reacts with a lag. Track leading indicators:

If the signs are bad, talk early. A wrong hire kept on longer costs more than a quick correction.

Conclusion

Hiring your first sales manager means swapping your presence for a system. It works when there's a process to manage, a builder profile, a 90-day plan and an owner willing to truly step out.

Want to prepare your operation before opening the position? Take Nexo's free assessment.
Take the free assessment

If process is still missing, see sales structuring. For management support while the company doesn't have this role, check out sales advisory.